CP
Cicero's Pizza
The Taste of Tradition in Every Slice
3.6
Restaurant
$$
The Taste of Tradition in Every Slice
Cicero's Pizza, located in San Jose, offers a charming, neighborhood pizza experience with a strong local following. Known for its freshly made pizzas with uniformly diced toppings, customers appreciate the thin crust and flavorful sauce. While some reviews note variations in the dining experience and service, the welcoming atmosphere and ample seating make it suitable for gatherings, including larger groups. With a rich history in the area, Cicero's remains a reliable choice for those craving classic pizza flavors with a local touch.
No photos available
Freshly made pizzas with thin crust, house-made sauce, and finely diced toppings, available in various sizes and styles.
Comfortable seating in a welcoming neighborhood setting, ideal for groups and casual dining.
Convenient options for pickup or delivery through partners like Foodie Earth, serving the Bay Area.
Build your own pizza with a wide selection of meats, veggies, and specialty toppings.
Complement your meal with fresh salads, garlic bread, and other classic Italian sides.
Perfect for parties and gatherings, offering large pizzas and group orders to feed a crowd.
Claim Cicero's Pizza to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
dayved black
Good pizza and chill staff. Lots of seating which was a nice suprise; however, this place does fill up amd it gets busy on a saturday night. FYI, we had a large group, about 12 adults and we had a great time. Thands Cicero's
Kristina Kouris
This is the third time l've had Cicero's delivered to me. This time I just got a large cheese pizza with a side salad. But l've had the veggie and meat toppings before and I love how finally diced everything is. They always spread the toppings nicely over the pizza. When I got my cheese pizza, it wasn't piping hot, but still a solid cheese pizza. I put a few slices in the air fryer and preferred the slices that were not warmed up. I'm curious as to what the pizza is like when in the store. A large cheese pizza and side salad delievered was $48 which is just crazy to me lol but I guess that's the times we're in. I used Foodie Earth for delivery, so even if you're far from Ciceros but still in the bay, you'll be able to get it!
Jim S.
Found it on onebite. Maybe its just an off day. I ordered a pizza I order at many other restaurants: cheese, jalapeno, pineapple, anchovy. The anchovy was not cooked, warm and very oily. It was gross and I left. Not worth $25. I had to keep repeating my order 3 times to the young girl and it seemed she was not all there. I told her no ice with the soda, put ice with the soda. She also kept touching her hair, drinking, touching customers food without washing her hands. Front of house is not sanitary at all. For the first time ever I almost threw up from how gross the pizza came out. I would not recommend this place. Disappointed.
Chelle T
A welcoming neighborhood pizza place. We tried 3 small pizzas to go with beer. Veggie, a combo and sausage. The veggies for all pizzas were uniformly cut so it spread throughout the pizza. The thin crust was great as well as the sauce. You order at the counter and they will call you when your order is ready. Napkins, parmesan cheese and peppers can be picked up at a side table. Service was nice and efficient.
Swapnil
“Visited Cicero’s Pizza in San Jose, a longstanding spot in the area that’s been around for years. It’s clear they’ve built a loyal following, and you can sense the nostalgia and local pride when you walk in. The pizza was good—definitely solid, but the flavors didn’t stand out as extraordinary. It had the basics down but didn’t have that extra flair to make it truly memorable. Still, it’s a reliable option if you’re in the area and craving pizza from a classic San Jose establishment.”
