CB
Cinotti's Bakery-Sandwich Shop
Jacksonville Beach's family-owned bakery and sandwich shop, serving fresh Italian-inspired delights since 1964.
4.4
Bakery
$
Jacksonville Beach's family-owned bakery and sandwich shop, serving fresh Italian-inspired delights since 1964.
Cinotti's Bakery-Sandwich Shop is a cherished family-owned establishment in Jacksonville Beach, Florida, operating since 1964. Known for its authentic Italian bakery items and delicious sandwiches, the shop offers a cozy atmosphere with the warm aroma of freshly baked goods. It provides a wide range of products, from custom cookies and pastries to hearty subs and coffee, using quality ingredients like Grounds of Grace coffee. The business continues a long-standing baking tradition, making it a local favorite for both everyday treats and special occasions.
No photos available
Daily selection of donuts, fritters, cinnamon rolls, breads, and pastries made from scratch.
Made-to-order sandwiches including meatball subs, chicken caesar croissants, and more on freshly baked rolls.
Beautifully decorated custom cookies and cakes for birthdays, holidays, and special occasions.
Freshly brewed coffee using local roasters like Grounds of Grace.
Take-home breads, pastries, and holiday treats for family gatherings and events.
Claim Cinotti's Bakery-Sandwich Shop to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
David Futch
I have been to Cinotti’s several times over the years and have never been disappointed. Living outside of JAX, I try to stop each time I am in town. Today’s visit was to get some donuts, fritters, cinnamon rolls, bread and Christmas cookies. Everything was excellent. This family owned business has been in JAX for 60 years and is absolutely worth the drive to come visit. Below is some AI generated information on Cinotti’s. Cinotti's Bakery has been in the Jacksonville Beach area since 1964, when Joe and Phyllis Cinotti opened their first bakery there, with the current popular location on Penman Road opening in 1990, continuing a family baking tradition that started in Cleveland and moved to Jax in 1955.
Nicole Cuevas
I cannot recommend this place enough! A true Italian bakery w/ no room for nonsense!… I can’t understand half these reviews hating on Ms. Janet. Ive had nothing but lovely conversations w/ her as she stops by to bus tables. I picture her role as the bouncer establishing order, and maintaining the integrity of the line so honestly if you get lip from her, you probably need to self reflect on your actions 😂 ,but anyways, onto their food- their sandwiches are delightful. Great lunch time pick me up. Pictured are the croissant chicken caesar and their meatball sub on an onion roll. I also love how they use grounds of grace for their coffee.
Tammy McGee
I picked up a cake two weeks ago that completely collapsed before it was ever served. It was embarrassing to open it at a birthday dinner and find it had fallen apart. I emailed Michelle, who initially responded that she would refund and replace the cake. However, after three follow-up emails over the next nine days asking how to handle the process, I never received a reply. I finally went into the store with my receipt and chose a simple replacement cake to deliver to the recipient. The employee took my receipt and email to Michelle, returned, and said, “that’s not what she meant.” When I asked for a refund instead, Michelle came to the counter herself, was rude and aggressive, refunded the cake, and refused to replace it. Terrible customer service — I will not be returning. Also worth noting: the business does not allow reviews or customer posts on social media, which makes me wonder if experiences like this are more common than people realize.
Rachel Ann
I couldn’t be happier with my order! The custom cookies were absolutely beautiful—every detail was so precise and exactly what I envisioned. Not only did they look stunning, but they tasted just as amazing (soft, fresh, and full of flavor). You can really tell how much care and creativity went into making them. Communication was easy, the process was stress-free! Thank you !
Miguel Rivera
This bakery is an absolute gem and a true town favorite! Every visit is a delight, from the moment you step in and are greeted by the warm, inviting aroma of freshly baked goods. Their pastries are consistently delicious and made with obvious care, It's clear why this place holds such a special spot in the hearts of locals – the quality, service, and cozy atmosphere make it a must-visit for anyone looking for a truly authentic bakery experience.
