OP
Osteria Pizzeria
Osteria Pizzeria: Bold pizzas, warm service, and neighborhood Italian charm.
5
Pizza
$$
Osteria Pizzeria: Bold pizzas, warm service, and neighborhood Italian charm.
Osteria Pizzeria in Columbus's Old Town serves pizza and Italian dishes with a welcoming neighborhood vibe. Guests praise attentive staff, quick service, and bar seating, perfect for watching a game. Signature items include cauliflower crust pizza, Numero Uno pizza, pollo pizza, peppers in oil, and Caesar salad, plus peach-season specials and peach cobbler for dessert. Dine-in or takeout is available.
No photos available
Hand-tossed pizzas with options like Numero Uno, vegetarian pesto, and seasonal peach pizza, featuring crispy crusts and fresh toppings.
Classic entrees such as Tagliatelle Bolognese with meatball, made with authentic recipes and high-quality ingredients.
Starters like Warm Olives in seasoned olive oil, Caesar salad, and peppers in oil, served with focaccia.
Sweet treats including peach cobbler with ice cream, plus a selection of cocktails like old fashioneds and peach whiskey drinks.
Full-service bar with attentive bartenders, indoor, patio, and bar seating, ideal for watching sports or casual gatherings.
Convenient takeout options that maintain quality, plus catering services for events and parties.
Claim Osteria Pizzeria to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
A T
Wonderful service by the employees-thank you!! Everything came out quickly and was so delicious. We got the peppers in oil, the numero uno pizza and the pollo pizza. Numero uno was our favorite—we’ll definitely be back!
Miles Q. Montegut
It was a Wednesday night, never been to DT Columbus and I was in the mood for Italian so I chose this place, in Old Town. The reviews weren’t great but it looked like a great menu, pics were good. I sat at the bar, service was prompt. It has a great neighborhood Italian atmosphere. Started off with a great old fashioned. I chose the Warm Olives for an appetizer. They were well bathed in seasoned olive oil and garlic, with a large serving of focaccia. DELICIOUS! For the entree I had the Tagliatelle Bolognese with meatball. WOW! If I’m in Columbus again, definitely going back.
GD III
This pizza place is a must-try! The staff is fantastic, and the atmosphere is great. I've been on a quest to find new pizza places, and I stumbled upon this gem through Google reviews. I brought some true foodies with me, and we were all blown away by the pizza's flavor. The Caesar salad was equally impressive. I highly recommend this place and would give it a solid 10/10. The service was excellent, and the vibe is perfect for watching a football game or simply enjoying good company.
Karen Lehoux
Cauliflower Crust was nice and crunchy, not soggy at all…vegetarian with pesto sauce is highly recommend. A regular crust pizza for hubby, he loved it especially the crust. We sat at the bar and watched the kitchen throw dough. Bartenders were very attentive and friendly. Topped off the meal with peach cobbler! Don’t pass by without stopping in.
Let Jess Tell It
Visited in August for the peach-season specials. Only the cobbler was recommended to me, but I went for the peach pizza too — both were worth it. 🍕 Pizza: Sweet peaches, savory cheese, and a light char that balanced it all. 🍑 Cobbler: Topped with vanilla ice cream — the perfect finish. 🥃 Drinks: Both peach cocktails were good, but the whiskey one (small glass, big ice cube) was my favorite. Bonus: Takeaway tastes just as good as dining in — rare to find. Price: $20–$35 pp | Wait: Immediate seating | Noise: Moderate | Seating: Indoor, bar, patio | Parking: Lot & street | Kid-friendly: Yes | Wheelchair accessible: Yes
