TS
The Sicilian Butcher
Italian flavors, curated wines, and bold dining in Nashville.
4.8
Bar
$$$
Italian flavors, curated wines, and bold dining in Nashville.
Located at 475 Gray St #101 in Nashville, The Sicilian Butcher offers Italian-inspired dishes paired with a wine-forward dining vibe. Guests rave about attentive service from staff like Sara and Ashleigh, delicious items from bruschetta boards to lasagna, caprese, meatball ferris wheel, and cannolis and gelato. The setting is clean and comfortable, with generous portions and occasional front-of-house hiccups resolved by management.
No photos available
Enjoy authentic Sicilian dishes including handmade pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and signature meatballs.
Sip from a curated selection of wines, cocktails, and craft beers in a stylish setting.
Share bruschetta, cheese, and charcuterie boards perfect for groups and starters.
Indulge in homemade cannolis, gelato, and other sweet treats to end your meal.
Experience live music and a lively atmosphere during select evenings.
Host events and gatherings with customizable menus and dedicated service.
Claim The Sicilian Butcher to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Ron Ruback
Our server, Sara, was great! Very attentive and super friendly. The food was amazing! We had the meatball ferris wheel, lasagna, Margherita pizza, and Ricotta Nduja dip. Everything was great! The lasagna picture was after we scooped the larger piece out. We wanted to sample all of these and have leftovers lol They have lots of cannolis and Gelato too.
Luis Garcia
This establishment truly offers a fantastic dining experience, boasting excellent food, a great atmosphere, and affordable prices. However, potential patrons should exercise caution regarding the front-of-house service, especially if arriving without a reservation. We opted to wait at the bar, planning to enjoy drinks and a cheese board while waiting for a table. Unfortunately, the staff operating the bar area assumed we would be dining there, despite our explicit clarification that we were waiting for a proper table. When we reiterated that we did not wish to dine at the bar, the host aggressively argued with us, attempting to shift the blame for the misunderstanding onto us. Fortunately, a manager quickly intervened and resolved the situation with professionalism. Despite the initial setback with the service team, the quality of the food and the timely resolution from management warrant a second visit. I will definitely return another day to give this place another chance. Bon Appétit!
Jordan Carter
No need to leave a long drawn out expressive summary. Food was amazing Drinks was amazing. Cannolis was amazing And Sara was amazing and gave good advice. Even picked a pasta for me. Go.
Krissy Kokoski
Sicilian Butcher - you outdid yourself. So excited to try this place. Out server, Ashleigh, was amazing! Made the dining experience better and gave great recommendations! We started with the bruschetta board for our appetizer and highly enjoyed it. The caprese was my favorite. For dinner I had the chicken parm meatballs w pasta, which did not disappoint. Definitely make your way here, you will not be disappointed!
Jessica Prieto
Really enjoyed this restaurant! We ordered the Italian saganaki appetizer and it was excellent! Tangy melty cheese and grilled ciabatta. I would order it again. I ordered the bruschetta as my meal, picking four types, and my husband ordered the lasagna. He said it was the best lasagna he ever ate. While dense, the pasta itself was handmade and light and there were 10 layers. He highly recommends. I definitely recommend the bruschetta. Being able to pick several and try different ones was fun and they were tasty. These are large portions. We also ordered some cannoli to go which were excellent once we took them home. The setting and ambiance was nice, clean, crisp, but comfortable. The wait staff was great. If I could find anything to critique it would be for the hosts and hostesses to not seat three couples directly next to each other when the restaurant is empty. We arrived earlier than the dinner rush so there were only a few people in the restaurant. We were sat 2 ft away from a couple and then another couple came and was sat down 2 ft away from us but the entire restaurant was empty. It was hard to keep conversation when there are two other conversations happening within 2 ft on either side of you. If the restaurant had been busy, I could understand, and would not have minded, but it wasn't. It would have been nice to have a little bit of privacy especially since there were so many open tables. But other than that, I commend the restaurant. The food was great, they had a band and the music was wonderful. We will definitely be back.
