BM
Bake Me Happy
Bake Me Happy: Gluten-free bakery delights Columbus with tasty, safe treats.
4.4
Bakery
$$
Bake Me Happy: Gluten-free bakery delights Columbus with tasty, safe treats.
Bake Me Happy at 500 E Whittier St in Columbus is a gluten-free bakery known for tasty, safe treats. Reviews applaud faithful gluten-free recreations and items like cakes, cookies, and more, plus coffee, tea, and refrigerated goods. The shop moved to this location about two years ago, in a former post office, attracting strong foot and car traffic.
No photos available
Freshly baked items like muffins, blondies, pop tarts, and oatmeal cream pies, all celiac-safe and delicious.
Special-order gluten-free cakes for birthdays and celebrations, made to exceed expectations.
Ground coffee, tea, and ready-to-drink beverages served in a cozy café setting.
Dry goods, refrigerated items, and gluten-free beer available for purchase.
Bulk orders and catering for events, ensuring safe and tasty options for all guests.
Claim Bake Me Happy to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Ela Winters
It was okay. I have celiac so I can only really eat so much and it was nice to hear of a bakery that was gluten free but i’ve definitely had better. not bad though.
Regina Hunter
I have nothing bad to say about anything I tried! This was my first time here and I will definitely be back! I got the brown sugar pop tart, blondie, coffee cake muffin, brown sugar rice crispy treat, and an oatmeal cream pie! The blondie was my absolute favorite! It was sprinkled with coarse salt on top which made the seert flavor that much more pronounced! Nice and crumbly and soft! The oatmeal cream pie was fabulous! Reminded me of my childhood! The icing in the coffee cake muffin follows me into my dreams! It was soooo rich but not overpowering! The rice crispy treat was the least sweet I think, which was perfect because I ate it last definitely appreciated the flavor as opposed to the sweetness! Can't wait to try more items!
Kristen Lytle
Picking up a gluten free cake for my son's birthday. I had ordered ahead and it definitely passed all my expectations!
Hannah Roberts
Bake me happy isn’t just good for a gluten free bakery, they’re great for a bakery. Very faithful reproductions of gluten based baking that taste amazing, have amazing texture. We threw a party with a few celiac guests and had no problem proudly and safely serving them these amazing baked goods. Thanks so much!
J Crozier
By recommendation, I popped by Bake Me Happy to find a good treat. I ended up with a coffee cake muffin. It had cinnamon inside and frosting on top. The appearance was fantastic. I'm not used to gluten free, but I'm trying. So that I could eat it immediately, I got a chair out of my hatch and sat right there in the parking lot to enjoy it. It's cool to get a feel for the neighborhood. These guys have all sorts of ground coffee, gluten-free beer, tea, dry goods and refrigerated items, along with actual coffee shop items. This building used to be an old post office. They moved to this location about 2 years ago. It's a mile or so from the old spot, but has way better car and foot traffic. I would definitely have gotten some more stuff, but I'm about to have a hell of a day in Columbus. #onforkstoforks #eatlocal #foodie #coffeeshop #GlutenFree #donuts
